TLDR
- ProxyMTG is our top recommendation for printing complete 100-card Commander decks because its pricing drops to $0.55 per card at 100 cards.
- PrintMTG is particularly useful when a deck needs custom tokens, alternate artwork, custom frames, or a ready-to-edit preconstructed decklist.
- ProxyKing is the better choice for selected premium singles, foils, and curated land or staple sets.
- Always review the final 100-card list, artwork versions, double-faced cards, and token package before submitting the order. Fixing an error on-screen is free. Discovering it after delivery is a more ceremonial experience.
A Commander Deck Can Become Expensive Remarkably Fast
Commander players are very good at beginning with modest intentions.
The plan is usually to build a fun casual deck around an interesting legendary creature. Then the mana base gets upgraded. A few tutors appear. Someone suggests a stronger draw engine. Three hours later, the deck costs $1,400 and contains a card described as “essential” by a person who does not have to pay for it.
Knowing where to print MTG proxies for Commander decks gives players another option. A professionally printed proxy deck can be used to test an entire list, build a balanced collection of shared decks, protect valuable originals, or play expensive cards in casual groups that allow proxies.
The best printing service depends on the order. Complete decks, custom tokens, premium singles, and alternate-art projects are related jobs, but they are not identical.
The Best Places to Print MTG Proxies for Commander
Here is the practical breakdown.
| Printing Option | Best For | Main Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| ProxyMTG | Complete decks and large orders | Excellent 100-card and bulk pricing |
| PrintMTG | Custom artwork, tokens, precons, and full decks | Strong card-design and customization tools |
| ProxyKing | Premium singles, foils, and curated sets | Carefully selected ready-to-order products |
| Home printing | Temporary testing | Lowest immediate cost |
ProxyMTG: Best for Complete 100-Card Commander Decks
ProxyMTG is our first choice when the goal is to print an entire Commander deck at once.
Customers can paste or upload a decklist, search the card database, choose available printings, adjust quantities, and review the complete order before checkout. ProxyMTG’s pricing is structured specifically to reward deck-sized and bulk orders:
- 75 to 99 cards: $0.80 per card
- 100 to 199 cards: $0.55 per card
- 200 to 499 cards: $0.45 per card
- 500 to 999 cards: $0.35 per card
- 1,000 or more cards: $0.30 per card
A complete 100-card Commander deck therefore costs $55 before shipping and applicable taxes. Adding the deck’s tokens, emblems, and a few alternate options keeps the order within the same $0.55 pricing tier.
ProxyMTG says it prints on S33 German black-core cardstock, applies a UV coating, enhances files to at least 300 DPI, and uses precision die cutting. Customers can choose among available artwork and card versions, and selected double-faced cards are automatically printed on both sides.
This makes ProxyMTG a particularly good fit for:
- A complete 100-card Commander deck
- Two or more decks ordered together
- Large Commander playtesting packages
- Shared decks for a regular playgroup
- Commander cubes and battle boxes
- Multiple versions of a deck at different power levels
The main advantage is that the service treats the deck as a project rather than 100 unrelated products.
PrintMTG: Best for Custom Tokens and Alternate-Art Decks
PrintMTG also supports decklist uploads, set-version selection, preconstructed decklists, custom card designs, and bulk ordering.
Its published volume pricing currently follows the same useful structure, reaching $0.55 per card at 100 to 199 cards, $0.45 at 200 to 499, and $0.35 at 500 to 999. PrintMTG also states that it uses S33 German black-core stock and typically produces orders in approximately two business days.
The major reason to choose PrintMTG is its MTG Card Maker. The online builder supports custom artwork, editable card details, different frame templates, fan-made cards, reskins, and custom MTG tokens. Finished designs can be added to a print order alongside normal cards.
PrintMTG is especially useful when a Commander deck needs:
- A custom version of the commander
- Matching tokens and emblems
- Alternate-art basic lands
- A consistent frame treatment
- Custom reminder cards
- Fan-made cards for a private playgroup
- A preconstructed deck that will be modified before printing
The card maker is not necessary for an ordinary decklist. But it is helpful when the deck has a strong visual theme or produces enough game pieces to require its own small administrative department.
ProxyKing: Best for Premium Singles and Curated Sets
Not every Commander player needs all 100 cards printed.
Sometimes the deck already exists, but it needs a few expensive lands, a premium version of the commander, or additional copies of staples currently being moved between several decks.
That is where ProxyKing’s MTG proxy catalog makes more sense. ProxyKing focuses on individually selected cards, premium treatments, foils, alternate artwork, and ready-made products. Its MTG proxy sets are particularly useful for complete fetch land, dual land, shock land, and artifact cycles.
Use ProxyKing when the order consists of:
- Five to twenty premium singles
- A coordinated land cycle
- A foil or alternate-art commander
- Showpiece cards that will be seen every game
- Reserved List staples
- Selected upgrades rather than an entire deck
ProxyKing and ProxyMTG serve different needs. ProxyKing is the premium singles shelf. ProxyMTG is the deck-printing department. This is a useful distinction because declaring one service universally “best” usually means nobody has defined the job.
Start With a Legal 100-Card Decklist
A Commander deck contains exactly 100 cards, including the commander. Other than basic lands and cards with rules that specifically allow additional copies, the format is singleton. Color identity also limits which cards may be included. The ProxyKing Commander deckbuilding fundamentals guide provides a useful final check before printing.
Do not submit a decklist while it still contains:
- A sideboard copied from another format
- Multiple versions of the same card
- Cards outside the commander’s color identity
- Placeholder cards that were supposed to be replaced later
- 101 cards because cutting the final card felt emotionally difficult
- Thirty-three lands in a six-mana commander deck, unless disappointment is part of the theme
Most printing mistakes begin before the printer receives anything. The service can reproduce the submitted list very accurately. Unfortunately, that includes the bad decisions.
Decide Whether to Print All 100 Cards
There are three sensible approaches.
Print the Entire Deck
This provides the most consistent appearance, thickness, and shuffle feel. It is the cleanest choice for a new deck, shared Commander collection, battle box, or list that uses many expensive cards.
Print Only the Expensive Cards
This works well when most of the deck is already owned. Use opaque sleeves and make sure the printed cards are physically consistent enough that they cannot be identified from the back, edge, or feel.
Print the Uncertain Cards First
A smaller testing order is useful when twenty or thirty slots remain unsettled. Once the list performs properly, print the finished version.
ProxyKing’s guide to proxying a whole MTG deck compares temporary paper inserts, home printing, and professional print-on-demand cards in more detail.
Add Tokens Before Placing the Order
Tokens are easy to forget because they are not part of the 100-card decklist. They become considerably harder to forget when the deck creates six different game objects and someone is using an upside-down Forest to represent all of them.
Review every card that creates:
- Creature tokens
- Treasure, Food, Clue, Blood, Gold, or Map tokens
- Copies of permanents
- Emblems
- Role tokens
- Incubators
- Powerstones
- Experience or energy reminders
- Monarch, initiative, day, night, or city’s blessing markers
The ProxyKing MTG token guide explains why clearly identified tokens improve board-state tracking. Tokens begin outside the deck, so they can be added without disturbing the Commander card count.
Print more than one copy of frequently created creature tokens. A deck that regularly produces twelve Zombies does not become easier to understand because one Zombie card has a die showing twelve on it. It becomes an accounting exercise with artwork.
Choose Alternate Art Selectively
Alternate artwork can make a Commander deck feel cohesive, but it can also make basic card recognition unnecessarily difficult.
Use alternate art most aggressively on:
- The commander
- Signature creatures
- Important finishers
- Basic lands
- Tokens and emblems
- Simple cards with little rules text
Use conventional, readable printings for:
- Complicated combo pieces
- Cards with several abilities
- Modal double-faced cards
- Tutors and interaction that must be identified quickly
- Cards frequently played over webcam
ProxyMTG allows customers to select among available art and card versions. PrintMTG goes further by allowing customers to upload their own artwork and adjust frames through its card builder.
A good visual rule is to personalize the cards that define the deck while keeping utility cards easy to read. Not every Arcane Signet needs to become an interpretive art project.
Check Double-Faced Cards Carefully
Modern Commander decks frequently include modal double-faced cards, transforming permanents, battles, and other two-sided designs.
ProxyMTG automatically prints both sides when a double-faced card is selected. That is convenient, but the order should still be reviewed to confirm that the intended version was chosen.
For other printing methods, determine whether the service:
- Prints both card faces
- Requires separate front and back files
- Uses a generic proxy back
- Supplies two separate cards
- Expects the customer to use a checklist or helper card
Opaque sleeves remain the safest choice. A two-sided card should not announce its position in the library like a tiny cardboard informant.
Use Bulk Pricing Intentionally
The 100-card threshold matters because it creates a substantial price drop at both ProxyMTG and PrintMTG.
That means it can be economical to combine related needs into one order:
- The 100-card deck
- Ten to twenty tokens
- Alternate cards for uncertain slots
- A second version of the commander
- Common staples for the next build
- Replacement copies of heavily used cards
At ProxyMTG’s current tiers, moving from 99 cards at $0.80 each to 100 cards at $0.55 each reduces the total order price rather than increasing it. The pricing is applied to the full quantity, so stopping at 99 cards would be an unusually expensive commitment to numerical purity.
For playgroups, combining several decks can reduce the price further:
- 200 to 499 cards: $0.45 each
- 500 to 999 cards: $0.35 each
- 1,000 or more cards: $0.30 each
Group orders require more sorting after delivery, but Commander players were going to spend the evening sorting cards anyway.
Review the Final Order With a Checklist
Before checkout, confirm:
- The deck contains exactly 100 cards, including the commander.
- Every card matches the commander’s color identity.
- Quantities are correct.
- The selected artwork is readable.
- Double-faced cards have the correct front and back.
- Tokens and emblems have been added separately.
- Custom cards clearly identify themselves as proxies or playtest cards.
- All cards will be used in the same style of opaque sleeve.
- The playgroup or store permits proxies.
- The delivery schedule works for the intended game night.
That final review takes a few minutes. Reordering a missing card takes longer and generally involves more muttering.
Our Recommendation
For a complete 100-card Commander deck, ProxyMTG offers the best combination of decklist ordering, card-version selection, double-faced card handling, and aggressive bulk pricing.
Choose PrintMTG when custom tokens, personalized artwork, custom frames, or editable preconstructed decks are a major part of the project.
Choose ProxyKing when the order is smaller and the priority is premium singles, foils, alternate-art staples, or coordinated card sets.
The smart choice is not one printer for every possible order. It is matching the service to the deck.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to print a 100-card Commander deck?
ProxyMTG and PrintMTG currently list a price of $0.55 per card for orders containing 100 to 199 cards. A 100-card deck therefore costs $55 before shipping and applicable taxes.
Should tokens be included in the 100-card decklist?
No. Tokens, emblems, and reminder cards exist outside the Commander deck. Add them to the printing order separately.
Can I choose alternate artwork for every card?
ProxyMTG and PrintMTG allow customers to choose from available card versions. PrintMTG also provides a card maker for custom artwork and frame designs. Readability should remain the priority, particularly for complicated cards.
Should I print basic lands?
Printing the basic lands creates the most visually and physically consistent deck. Leaving them out can reduce the number of cards being printed, but may also prevent the order from reaching the 100-card price tier.
Can I print double-faced MTG cards?
Yes. ProxyMTG states that selected double-faced cards are automatically printed on both sides. Other services may have different file or ordering requirements, so verify the process before checkout.
Are professionally printed Commander proxies tournament legal?
No. These cards are intended for casual play and deck testing where proxies are permitted. Ask the store, event organizer, or playgroup before using them.