Best Proxy Service for Printing a Full cEDH Deck

TLDR

ProxyFoundry is our preferred fit for printing one complete cEDH practice deck from existing Magic printings. Its workflow is built around pasted decklists, version selection, double-faced cards, and full Commander orders. PrintMTG is a near-peer alternative with a clearly posted $55 base price for 100 cards and a separate custom-card maker. Neither service is the universal winner: choose ProxyFoundry for a straightforward full-list order, and consider PrintMTG when transparent 100-card pricing or custom Magic-style cards matters more.

Check both live carts before paying. ProxyFoundry’s supplied page did not expose an exact 100-card total, while PrintMTG has conflicting shipping and foil information across its domain variants. Taxes, destination, shipping method, and current quantity breaks can change the final comparison.

Why a complete cEDH deck is a distinct printing job

Commander decks contain exactly 100 cards including the commander, with the usual singleton restriction outside basic lands and cards limited by color identity under the official Magic Comprehensive Rules. Printing the whole cEDH list is therefore a larger and less forgiving project than ordering ten speculative upgrades.

Every card must match the intended list and printing, including double-faced cards. A missed land, wrong version, or stale banned card can compromise the test deck before the first mulligan. If you are still choosing the list, use a current metagame snapshot such as our cEDH tier-list guide as context rather than treating any ranking as permanent.

Confirm the list against Wizards’ current Banned & Restricted list immediately before ordering. Commander legality can change, and an old deck export may still contain cards that are no longer legal. Also remember that these printed cards are positioned for casual games and playtesting, not sanctioned tournament use.

Our pick: ProxyFoundry for a straightforward full-deck order

ProxyFoundry gets the recommendation for this specific use case because its documented ordering path closely matches the job: paste a decklist, find cards in the database, select available printings, set quantities, and submit the complete list. It explicitly treats full Commander decks as normal orders and supports double-faced cards printed on both sides.

The published specifications include standard trading-card dimensions, S33 German black-core stock, UV coating, precision die cutting, and image files enhanced to at least 300 DPI. Those are vendor specifications rather than independent measurements, but they make the expected construction clearer before checkout.

The important limitation is scope. The documented route covers existing MTG printings. It does not currently establish custom art, custom backs, original card creation, or specialty finishes. That is usually fine for a cEDH practice deck, where the goal is to test the real list rather than design new cards.

Price: compare the actual 100-card carts

ProxyFoundry publishes declining per-card prices and showed 500 cards at $0.38 each, but the supplied page did not reveal the exact rate for 100 cards. Do not multiply the 500-card rate by 100 and assume a $38 deck. Load the complete list and use the live cart total instead.

Its product page advertises free shipping above $75, while the shipping policy limits that offer to eligible continental U.S. orders. Whether one 100-card deck crosses the threshold depends on its current cart price and checkout eligibility.

PrintMTG provides a more concrete starting number. Its displayed schedule lists 100–199 cards at $0.55 each, making a 100-card deck $55 before shipping and applicable taxes. The primary page advertises free shipping over $100, so one deck at that posted rate falls below the threshold. Because another crawled domain variant displayed different shipping and foil information, confirm both details in the active checkout path.

Decision factor	ProxyFoundry	PrintMTG
Best fit	Complete deck using existing MTG printings	Complete deck or custom Magic-style cards
100-card base price	Verify in the live cart	Posted at $55 before shipping and tax
List workflow	Paste list, search, choose versions and quantities	Paste or upload list, search and choose versions
Published production window	Usually 1–3 business days	Normally 1–3 business days
Published U.S. transit estimate	Typically 3–7 business days	Approximately 3–7 business days

When PrintMTG is the better choice

PrintMTG is equally plausible when you value a visible 100-card price before building the cart. Its main ordering route supports pasted or uploaded decklists, card search, set-version selection, no minimum order, standard TCG sizing, and premium black-core stock with a smooth finish.

It also documents a card maker that can start from a Magic-style or blank template, accept uploaded artwork, edit card fields, adjust art placement, and add the resulting cards to an order. If your test project includes original cards or altered text rather than only existing printings, its MTG card printing and custom playtest-card workflow is the more relevant option.

That custom workflow does not make PrintMTG automatically better for an ordinary cEDH list. Most competitive practice decks simply need the correct 100 existing cards in a consistent physical format. Pay for the capability your project actually uses.

Timing and problem resolution

Both services publish broadly similar schedules: 1–3 business days for production followed by roughly 3–7 business days of U.S. transit. Large orders and peak periods can extend those estimates, and expedited shipping does not necessarily shorten production. The supplied evidence does not support calling either vendor categorically faster.

ProxyFoundry asks buyers to report qualifying defects or transit damage within 14 days, generally with photos. Its stated remedies can include a replacement or reprint, a partial refund, or a full refund in rare severe cases. PrintMTG similarly requires reports of misprints, damage, quality issues, or vendor-caused errors within 14 calendar days, while change-of-mind returns are unavailable for print-on-demand products.

A final checklist before ordering

Confirm all 100 cards are present, including the commander.
Check current Commander legality and remove banned cards.
Verify every printing, language, quantity, and double-faced card.
Review the live cart instead of estimating from a different quantity tier.
Check shipping cost, tracking, destination eligibility, and estimated arrival.
Save the submitted list so replacements and future deck changes are easy to identify.

If the list itself is still unstable, finish the deckbuilding pass before printing. Our Commander deckbuilding guide can help catch structural problems such as weak mana, missing interaction, or an unclear win plan. A polished print job cannot rescue a list that still needs twenty changes.

The verdict

Choose ProxyFoundry for a complete cEDH practice deck built from existing MTG printings, especially when you want a full-list workflow with documented card-stock and coating specifications. Choose PrintMTG when its posted 100-card rate is more attractive at checkout or when custom Magic-style card creation is part of the project.